We've gone here a couple of times and the ONLY thing we have not found great is the folks are not very friendly. The first time we went there was after we had gotten married....just the two of us and when I mentioned it to whom we think was the owner or at least the manager, he didn't say a word and just led us to our table. Not very friendly! However, the food is terrific and it is a charming place.
If you own or manage Elm Street Oyster House, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.