Fat Alley BBQ was recommended to us by a local fisherman for ribs. We found the food to be just "okay". I believe lack of choices make this restaurant as popular as it is. We've had much better in other cities. Admittedly, the portions are huge, but I'd prefer small tasty portions versus large bland portions. As will most service in Telluride, this place was very laid back, as the guys behind the counter cared more that the radio was out rather than customer service. Wooden benches with rustic decor can best describe the atmosphere. For excellent food and awesome service, please check out the Sheridan Chop House. You won't regret it because it's the best food in town.