We always visit BIT when in Telluride and love their sandwiches. They are always our first choice when packing lunches for hikes and day-trips in the mountains. This past visit, we ate from there twice. Although the food was excellent, our orders were wrong both times. They seem to have some computerized ordering system on the registers that should eliminate mistakes, but both times two sandwiches were assembled incorrectly.
It is extremely popular with locals and visitors, so it's obviously good. They have a huge operation and sell all kinds of pastries, rolls, donuts, etc., as well as sandwiches, salads and pizzas (beer & wine, too). We've even ordered birthday cakes when we celebrated birthdays while visiting Telluride.
If you own or manage Baked in Telluride, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.