We stayed as Wyndham owners in Lakeside Meadows (2 bedroom with loft, sleeper sofa in living room and loft) for 3 nights in July. These units appear older than most but are well maintained with panel tv's, fireplace, full kitchen with two rear decks facing lake and San Juan Mountains. Beautiful views! Also very close to rec center.
Enjoyed rec center with indoor pool, hot tub, racquetball and way above average gym. The mini golf is a must do, we enjoyed several rounds at different parts of the day.
You could play tennis and golf nearby. Didn't see anyone fishing on the grounds?
Wyndham gave us a discount card that saved us 10-20% at several eateries and retailers.
If in Pagosa Springs, we would stay again.