The meal at this restaurant was by far the worst that I have ever experienced. On Feb. 10, 2010 we arrived at the restaurant to find it almost empty at 7 PM and decided to have a drink at the bar. When we were seated in the restaurant at 8 PM we were advised that they were already out of the daily special. After finally choosing from the limited menu, we served ourselves at the salad bar (the best part of the meal). I ordered crab stuffed dover sole with baby potatoes and sauteed vegetables, my wife ordered mahi mahi with pepper relish. When served, my plate contained 4 plain boiled potatoes, 2 stacks of sliced yellow squash with one slice of zuchinni and 3 slices of carrot, all of which were rubbery and unseasoned. Stacking the vegetables like pancakes was one of the worst presentations that I have seen and I can't believe that an experienced chef would allow something like that to leave the kitchen. The entree looked like something that was purchased in the frozen food section of a supermarket and thawed just prior to serving. The sole was dry, almost resembling freezer burned meat, with the color of something that had been left on the counter for a couple of hours and the stuffing had the flavor of something from a box. Completely awful presentation and completely inedible. My wife could not taste the mahi mahi due to the fact that the "pepper relish" actually looked and tasted like a jar of Ragu had been dumped on the fish. Again, completely terrible presentation and overwhelming taste. When asked by the server how our meals were and receiving no comment, even though both plates had been almost untouched, the reaction was to remove the plates and ask if we needed to see the desert menu, which we declined. The prices on the menu are not necessarily exorbitant, but certainly can't be justified by the quality of our food. We own a vacation home in the Keystone area and had never eaten at this restaurant before. We certainly won't be returning. If I could give a rating lower than 1, I would.
P.S. My wife was sick in the middle of the night after a few bites of her terrible fish.
If you own or manage Summit Seafood Co, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.