The Kickapoo has the atmosphere of most of Keystone. Log buildings and mountain decor. It was one of the few restaurants available for the evening meal. The food was acceptable , but the prices are on the high side. We went to the restaurant for a family meal. The waitress was prompt and polite, but seemed annoyed we weren't drinking and didn't order an appetizer. The steak I ordered was prepared as requested. The meals were prepared well. A taco meal was ordered and came with two small tacos, really appetizer size. They were served with beans and rice that weren't even mentioned on the menu. The special for the evening was trout which was excellent.
If you own or manage Kickapoo Tavern, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.