I stayed at this hotel twice and would stay again -- beautiful, comfortable, great friendly staff, nice breakfast, perfect location.Only thing to check carefully is the size of the room you are booking. I booked a room with two queen beds and it was huge. Next stay I booked a room with a queen and single and it was tiny. I would stay again in a heartbeat, but I would just look carefully at the room size.
I also stayed in the General Palmer, which has a similar feel and would pick the Strater over it -- the Strater is more lively and has a better breakfast.