My wife and I have made several trips to Crested Butte, and the Lodge at Mountaineer Square has by far the best staff and service. The rooms have a great lodge feel and you can't go wrong with the location. They offer both valet parking and self parking and although it is $15 a day the location of the garage is very convenient.
The staff at the concierge is top notch and the front desk staff are always eager to help.
Do yourself a favor and go downstairs and eat at DJANGOS! This restaurant is the best in all of Crested Butte and is a foodies paradise.