I had the BBQ sandwich and fries and it was mediocre but that was expected. I really just wanted to eat outside and enjoy the views on a full stomach. If you have to have a fabulous meal ever time then this isn't the place for you. However if you can handle what amounts to cheap ballpark/concert food then take a break to enjoy the setting.
If you own or manage Cafe at the Garden, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.