We had dinner here on our last night (06/04/07)in Buena Vista and were quite pleased with the food. Their menu changes daily. (we were informed upon entering, to look over their menu to be sure we saw something that we wanted. I thought this was courteous of them) The food was delicious, their salad dressings are homemade and yummy. We had their steaks and they were juicy and cooked to order. The wait staff was very friendly also. Reasonably priced.

We had the pleasure of dining at the Buffalo Bar and Grill on May 22nd, 2007. I had called ahead to see if they could accomodate our party of 40 high school seniors as well as 11 adults. The owner personally handled the entire dinner and gave us 5 choices for an entree. The smoked prime rib was some of the best I have ever experienced as well as the Salmon with dried cranberries. The view of Mt. Princeton from the dining room window was postcard perfect.

The service was outstanding and the quality of the food was excellent and we will be back again next year.

I completely disagree with the two negative reviews. The food was amazing and the service was great. The owner and the chef made a point to talk to each table and they were really friendly. The menu changes daily but if you are ever there when they serve salmon I recommend it!

I was a little hesitant to go here after reading the other 2 reviews; however, I was visiting my brother and sister-in-law that live just outside of BV and they suggested the Buffalo when I told them I would take them to dinner. We had a waitress that was very friendly and that was even after my brother sent his steak back 2 times. My brother likes his steaks very well done (burnt) so he sent it back when it didn't have a crust on the outside. I had the smoked pork ribs and they were good. The salad was ok but not the best in the world. Overall I would say the food was average to good and the service was good.