Ig Vella's place is amazing! We are there like once a week to stock up. My favorite is the Mezzo Secco, a jack cheese that has won awards nationwide - beating out wisconsin cheese makers! (This stuff is G-O-O-D!!) Other favorites of people in my family are the Toma (a soft somewhat creamy italian style cheese), and i also like the smoked blue cheese they bring in. Plus, in season, the parking lot is ringed by blackberry bushes! Skip the plaza places, just go here, its worth the walk. Take the bike trail, its literally like 2 blocks from the plaza.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.