After reading the reviews I took the punt and booked 4 nights in an ocean-view suite early August. A little pricey at about $280/n + tax. Self, wife and a 1 yr old - also booked a second room for parents in-law who were our travel companions.
Georgian was as quirky as other reviewers made out, renovated from the 30's but not near modern, so expect to put up with a few missing mod-cons. The "old" elevator works if you close the door - not hard to remember. Breakfast (included by voucher) on the balcony was as good as it gets. Just be aware to have 20 minutes to spare in case of wait for table, especially close to finishing time.
Front desk manager was worse then useless at check-in. Requested early check-in well in advance and got non-committal reassurance and after 14 hour flight from Australia were forced to wait (very jet-lagged) 4 hours for one room, the other still wasn't ready for another 2 hours, then wasn't even on the same floor.
Odd thing happened to in-laws: got worse housekeeping after leaving a tip than when they forgot on first night!
Position is great, but lack of room balcony meant the views were wasted. Food in r'rant next door (they do room service menu) great.
Overall I'd say it was a lovely place to stay, but next time I'll go to the Holiday Inn (or whatever) close to 3rd St. But if you have to visit L.A. then Santa Monica is the place to stay.

We just returned from a 2 night stay at The Georgian Hotel. Our city view suite on the 8th floor provided us a view of the ocean, mountains and the city of Santa Monica. It was very spacious and comfortable; two rooms--one with a king size bed, a large living room area, and a double-entry bathroom containing two sinks. The staff was friendly and helpful, the drinks on the terrace watching the sunset were great (although the noise level is very high because of the buses going by constantly), valet parking service was always prompt, and breakfast was yummy, served with a smile. We had the suite, breakfast and valet parking all for less than the cost of a dinky hotel room in some of the more pricey hotels---none of which have the character and charm of The Georgian. It truly is a gem!

I liked the look of this Hotel and read good reviews before i paid an extortionate amount of money to stay here for 2 nights in August at($296/night). The Hotel was advertised as full of character which to a certain extent it had, however the building and its internal fabric are too old. The bathroom tiles, lighting, are still original art deco, and so are many of the fixtures and fittings, whilst this maybe authentic it looks decidedly shabby.
Dont be conned by thinking you are getting an Ocean view as a good deal, the noise from the traffic outside is horendous, you will be better off at the side or back of the hotel where rooms are quiter. None of the rooms are double glazed so some of the rooms can be drafty as well as noisy. Car parking is extra at $15/ night. The only positive thing i can say about the hotel is that it is idealy situated for Santa Monica Pier and 3rd Street Promenade, but my honest opinion is that you can get a better Hotel in the same location for less money. Staff where helpful.

Very pleased that we chose the Georgian - having read reviews here. Booked a city view suite for us (2 adults & teenage son). Huge rooms, quiet, very clean, good quality furniture - comfy bed!
Staff exceptionally helpful and pleasant.