First note: This is just an ice cream store. Not a restaurant. The space is small with very limited outdoor seating... like for 2, I think. I just take mine to go.
I love chocolate so much that I've never tried any of the other innovative flavors. But I hear good responses to the other flavors. Happily, though they change most of their flavor offerings, they always have the chocolate sorbet. It seems like a rich ice cream to me, and the most chocolatey I've had anywhere. I've been there several times, though I really try not to eat ice cream generally.
If you own or manage The Penny Ice Creamery, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.