This is a great old hotel, and a perfect alternative to predictable cookie cutter chain properties. Now, you can read a lot into that sentence...
It is an old hotel. Not everything can stay in perfect condition for over 100 years. I hope I can look that good when I'm that age. I think the management has done a fine job keeping the original look and feel while making sure the doors seal, the locks lock, and the fixtures function. The updates aren't too out of place, unlike some older-but-updated hotels.
It's an alternative to chain hotels. If you like your soulless predictable room, generic hotel bar, and adjacent parking garage, go book the Sheraton. I've stayed there, it's nice.
The weekend rates are pretty spectacular. We paid $89, and it was well worth twice that. The In-Room Jacuzzi was large enough to bathe an elephant. The rest of the room was quite spacious, the fridge was a helpful touch. The bed was more than comfortable, and the amenities were of good quiality.
As a Saturday guest of the hotel, we were entitled to 50% off Sunday brunch in the outdoor restaurant. It was without a doubt the best $16 meal I've ever had. King Crab, shrimp, steak, desserts, mimosas, all a great experience.
The neighborhood is great, you can easily walk to a Blues Bar, a brewery, nightclubs, restaurants, shopping, but the hotel itself is in a quiet semi-residential area.
I honestly have no idea why the property has rated so poorly here. I think it's great, and I am a highly seasoned traveler--9 months a year for the last 7 years. Maybe I got lucky.