I'd give this grill a poor rating because I went away hungry, and I'm a light eater. But the food was really tasty and fresh - made to order. There is a $6 lunch special. I ordered the Mahi Wrap with cole slaw to go. I waited 15 minutes because the food is prepared fresh (at 1:30 they weren't busy).
The food was served in a large plastic tray with lid, so I expected a nice size lunch. Boy, was I disappointed. The 2 Mahi fish pieces were nicely seasoned with a light tasty sauce and each was tucked in a leaf of butter lettuce. Each piece in its lettuce wrap was less than 2" long. The lettuce leafs were larger - you almost could have double-wrapped the fish. One big bite per wrap, or 3 really little ones if you want to make it last. The excellent cole slaw was about similar in size.
What a shame. It's a very friendly, attractive spot with a nice band stage and simple, brightly colored decor. I'll come back some night for their live music, but I think I'll eat beforehand.
If you own or manage Sammy's Rockin' Island Bar & Grill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.