We had a nice time, decent food and nice enough atmosphere. You do seem to be in a time warp, which isn't always a bad thing. This is not the place for a lasting memory but if you need a decent place with some atmosphere, you could do much worse. The service was sketchy and trying to be fine dining, but it missed the mark.
If you own or manage Shame on the Moon, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.