We have lived in Mt. Shasta for almost 20 years and have dined at the Highland House Restaurant many many times. Unfortunately, this restaurant has never lived up to the gorgeous views and beautiful interior. The food quality is sort of like a roller coaster...sometimes it is quite good but more often than not, the food is mediocre at best. A few weeks ago we dined in a party of six. We so much want to frequent and support the local economy of Mt. Shasta but this restaurant is often at the bottom of our list of choices. One couple in our group ordered the petite rib-eye steaks from a "winter" menu (not the full menu offered now only Thursday-Sunday). The steaks were about 1/2 inch thick and certainly didn't look or taste like rib-eye steaks. They were tough, overcooked and lacked any flavor. The asparagus was on the raw side and just poorly prepared. The mashed potatoes looked like boxed potatoes and were gummy and don't ask about the dry gravy on top. Others ordered the eggplant parmesana which was served with a heavy penne-type pasta side-dish. The eggplant was okay but lacked flavor and was hardly a stellar dish. Fortunately, the beverages from the bar and the dinner salads were tasty! As for our server, he was a kind and attentive young man. His sheepish looks as we ate our meals felt like a confirmation that he, too, felt sorry and embarrassed about the poor food quality and preparation. We so want to like this restaurant but it lacks the touch of a professional chef. This restaurant should be the crown jewel of all of the restaurants in Mt. Shasta but has never achieved that level as the Resort seems unwilling to hire and pay for a great chef with a creative vision. We have found over the years that the Resort pub and its bar menu is a much better choice for a meal. The bar has atmosphere, a great staff and the food is almost always in the good to very good range. It will be a long time before we return to the Highland House Restaurant which seems to be the mantra of most permanent residents of the area.
If you own or manage Highland House Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.