We ate here for lunch while taking a walk on the pier and after checking web reviews. The Monterey, Carmel, Pacific Grove area offers so many great restaurants and after seeing good reviews. I though this was another...sadly that was not the case. It is a nice place and to be fair the service was very good, but amongst the four of us at the table we had a very good seafood casserole, a very mediocre turkey sandwich, a so-so kind of blah hot crab sandwich and a very poor pasta dish that wouldn't even qualify for a Chef Boyardee label. So as a very disappointing experience, I doubt I will ever return.
If you own or manage Old Fisherman's Grotto, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.