I went several times over the last weekend in December (2012). Obviously it's good enough to go back, though the food was unimpressive. I ordered some sort of toasted chicken sandwich and was really disappointed. It tasted like the chicken sandwich from Nicoletti's on campus at the UCen, except it wasn't as good. (And it was significantly more expensive!)
I kept going back for the cupcakes. Between myself and my three friends over the weekend we tried six different flavors--approximately half of the flavors in the display case--and we loved them all. $3 is a little pricey for a regular-sized cupcake, but they're good for a once-in-a-while treat. (And according to a friend who still lives in IV, the minis are a better deal, price-wise.)
So really, that four star review is due ENTIRELY to the delicious cupcakes. Don't bother looking for a real meal there.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.