We were here at the end of the tourist season and by mid-afternoon were only the 2nd couple to have been there all day. The young woman in charge told us they were closing in a couple of days and so unfortunately there was little on offer except cookies/pastry and coffee. So, two lattes and macaroons. This is a lovely spot, there is a stage for music (none while we were there) and overall it's in a beautiful location at the end of the road (like many places in Iceland). Someday, we'll go back when they're truly up and running.
If you own or manage Alfacafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.