We booked two Rustic Rooms for our one night stay. These rooms have not been refurbished but were very clean, well appointed and comfortable - if just a little dated (with a tiny bathroom!). However for the price we paid (which is very reasonable for Carmel) we were happy with our rooms and highly recommend the property. The receptionist was very helpful and efficient.
The big bonus for our family was the hotels' location in Carmel - close to the main street with it's excellent shopping and restaurants.
We highly recommend a visit to A W Shucks for drinks and dinner - great food, great ambience and resonably priced.