We almost always save a night for DeVitto's when we vist Eureka Springs. We love their trout dishes. They also often served grilled salmon which we have found very satisfactory. Yes, the restaurant is very small, but to us that adds to the ambiance. We like it because it is very cozy.
The only negatives I have are their cocktails are very small for the price and they don't take reservations for dinner. However you can get on the list and stroll around downtown while you wait.
If you own or manage DeVito's of Eureka Springs, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.