I've been to Dominical several times and always returned to El Coco. The food is great here, basic Costa Rican, similar to what you'd get anywhere else, but you always get a big portion, and the prices are more than reasonable. They're the best in town.
The breakfast here is particularly good. Also the arroz con mariscos is quite tasty.
One negative thing we would have to say about El Coco is that probably 50% of the time we were in this restaurant, we saw girls working as prostitues entertaining tourists. It was very obvious, and might make some people uncomfortable. We just turned the other way and enjoyed our food.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.