What a cute little place! Love the pink, white and black decor..the black booths are comfy, but I noticed a few tables with chairs that were darling too. Previous reviewer mentioned something about needing an overhaul..it must have been done because I noticed nothing needing reupholstered or painted or anything. It's a very cute and quaint place.
My very pregnant friend took me here specifically for the ice cream..we only had ice cream. Oh the choices! There are so many neat concoctions that you can order..we kept it simple and ordered a single scoop. I had coffee flavor, my friend had flavor of the day which was some sort of caramel/macadamia nut (I can't remember exactly but it was heavenly!) and another friend tried the peppermint bark. Their servings are very generous and prices are reasonable. "One" scoop ($2.75) was actually three little scoops in an ice cream dish (we ordered cup not cone)! Very creamy scrumptious ice cream. The coffee had a nice flavor, not too sweet; the peppermint bark was very refreshing and "minty". The staff is dressed in 50s retro, even their make up. They all looked darling and the service was super friendly. There were lots of families there and a nice patio that would be great to sit out on when it's cooler. Will definitely go back for more ice cream :-)
If you own or manage Mary Coyle Ice Cream, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.