This is more a selection of houses within the complex than a hotel - but that was perfect. We had a wonderful two/three bedroomed house. It was very clean, quiet and spacious (although they were having a bit of an ant problem in the bathroom which was sorted out as soon as we mentioned it). Special mention must go to Jeffrey (one of the staff). He has apparently been there for years, does everything and is the most positive person in the world. He always made us smile.

My only criticism was the speed of service and quality of food in the Bell Tavern. The main restaurant was great but I would stick to drinks in the Tavern.

Currently staying at the manor and we love every bit of it. Nice accommodation with exquisite gardens in a residential estate. As we love to cycle the place is quite ideal with a lovely pass and views over Knysna. Only downside would be the restaurant choice in the area that is limited - you have to travel to Knsyna which is about 15 minutes away where there is lots of choice. However we would recommend irrespective !

Our family of four all agreed that Belvidere Manor is one place we should plan to return to. We were provided a chalet with three bedrooms, a lounge area and kitchen, offering the option to self-cater. The chalets are set out across well-manicured lawns, with our rooms being very comfortable, two with en-suite bathrooms. Although we experienced a bit of ‘braai-envy’ at our neighbours who had chosen this route for dinner we decided to try out The Bell, the restaurant on pub on the manor’s estate. Big mistake! We arrived at 7pm and received our salad starters nearly two hours later. Why did we not cut our losses and move on earlier? We had already consumed a bottle of wine before we realised the kitchen was in trouble, so driving anywhere was not an option. Anyway, we eventually got fed and the food was pretty good. That experience aside, it did not diminish our Belvidere Manor experience and after a wonderful breakfast the next morning we departed, planning to return.

We spent over 2 weeks at Belvidere Manor. We had a lovely 3 bed cottage which was plenty big enough for us (2 adults, 2 children). Let me start by saying how beautiful the setting is, the lawns are perfectly manicured, the view is amazing and wonderful pool was a stunning attraction for the kids. We really relaxed and enjoyed our time in Knysna. It's a lovely location near Brenton on Sea and Brenton on Lake and only a 5 min drive to the Waterfront. As we were here in 'silly season' things were very busy so we often stayed around the resort with a book and the pool. For the cottage and surroundings this place is fabulous and we would recommend it for families, couples and anyone wanting some peace and tranquility. It's so peaceful and the lagoon nearby is wonderful. The gregarious and friendly Jeffrey was on good form for the holiday and is a lovely guy and very helpful. The cottage could have been better equipped in the kitchen, but generally everything was there and we could cook as necessary. DSTV for the evenings and a DVD player although we had to ask for a cable as it wasn't in the cottage. The showers are a great pressure and the maid came everyday and was pleasant and quick. It was frustrating not being able to use the washing machine in the cottage (only for the owners) and if we hadn't had people living close by would have had to pay hotel prices for washing (and there's a lot of that with 2 kids). As a place to holiday in , totally wonderful and we will be back in a flash.

The minor irritations concern mostly the food and some other service related problems.

We were B&B and at the beginning of the holiday the breakfast was great. Lots of lovely fruit, meat platters and a nice cooked breakfast. As we got later in to the holiday and it got busier, things slipped and there were major issues with seating (shade) and the last day the milk was sour, the granola was going stale and the meat platter consisted of leftover turkey from the xmas lunch 3 days prior. Really not the standard it should have been. Also, no one apologises EVER for things such as sour milk!!

Quite a few mornings we went for early swims around 7.15am. The pool is 'open from 7am' and all the wet towels from the previous day were still lying around and no clean ones out, and the pool hadn't been cleaned.

There is a major issue with shade. Breakfast is generally set up on the stoop of the manor, but by 7.30/8am on a hot day you get burnt alive and there is no way to block the sun on the stoep. So, you can eat on the patio where there are umbrellas. Unfortunately rarely were tables set up on the patio so nearly every day we had to wait whilst someone reset the table. For the life of me I couldn't understand why this wasn't done as standard as everyone wanted shade (lots of families and kids in buggies) Shade also ruined xmas lunch for some families and really a retractable marquee is needed.

Xmas lunch - if you're there again, don't bother. It was a nice idea but poorly executed and managed as though it was the first one ever done. The service was poor, the shade was poor, the watermelon gazpacho looked like sick (out of the mouth of babes...) the turkey was dry and we were lucky as we got there early, but people were complaining after waiting over 1.5 hours for their food! There were a few complaints and grumblings between residents.

Generally the staff are so nice and it just appears they have no proper leadership when it comes to managing a hotel of this rating. Everyone is eager to please but something was lacking in this stay.

Service and food also inconsistent at the Bell Tavern on site (I will leave another review)

The points above are to mainly help the hotel to rectify some of the shortfalls as it really is a stunning place and rectifying the above would make it totally perfect, after all, it has 4 stars.