First if all, this is quite an imposing hotel in a very interesting area of Cape Town. On entry, you are aware of a spectacular atrium. There's also a bar on the top floor adjacent to a beautifully designed swimming pool. There's something beguilingly surrealisitic about the street sounds floating up from down below as you swim through the water. The chic bar also doubles as a breakfast location.
Just up the road you will find the infamous Slave House (which was operated by the Dutch East India Company and is a testament to man's inhumanity to man) and the luxuriant and almost-tropical Company Gardens, as well as the National Art Gallery and the Jewish Museum. Unlike the Waterfront, this area beside the Mandela Rhodes gives you a feel for the real 'Cape Town' and it is both a delight and a privilege to be surrounded by indigenous South Africans (as opposed to tourists) when you walk your way down either Adderley Street or Long Street. Another option is to take the ten minute walk through Company Gardens and have the delicious afternoon tea on offer at the Mount Nelson hotel al fresco in the midst of the beautiful weather Cape Town is currently experiencing.
Unfortunately, I arrived at this hotel on the night of March 2nd during a week when Cape Town was literally bulging at the seams (hosting both a cycle race and an anaesthetist's conference). On arrival, I produced my Venere booking confirmation number. The woman behind the main desk told me that the Mandela Rhodes had not received my Venere booking for the 3 days through to March 5th. The duty manager then told me that he had never heard of Venere (even though I pointed it out to him on the Tripadvisor website as one of the four main booking agencies listed in connection with the Mandela Rhodes hotel). In the end, they gave me one night in a large apartment., and told me I would have to go elsewhere for the remaining two nights.
My apartment at the Mandela Rhodes was very large with two bedrooms and two bathrooms. Definitely comfortable. But I do not share the views of some of the other posters on this site about the quality of the internal decor. It reminded me more of Sallynoggin in Ireland than Cape Town. The kitchen fittings had a boring, bog standard look to them, and the floral pattern on the couch was more 1950s than the year 2008. That said, however, the bedrooms (though small) were very cosy and the shower was powerful and soothing after a long day in the sun.
In the end, Junior, one of the managers, phoned me to my room on the morning of the 3rd of March to tell me that he had secured accommodation for me for two days across the street for circa Euro 70 a night. I was moved to a brand new hotel fifty metres away (the Holiday Inn Express) which was absolutely fine. So, though I'm very critical of the Mandela Rhodes for failing to honour my Venere booking in the first place (for which I had a specific confirmation number), I am grateful to Junior, the duty manager who retrieved what could have been a very difficult situation for me (given that virtually every other hotel in Cape Town was booked out during what was essentially a very busy week).
Finally, I would reiterate my earlier comment about the centre of Cape Town. Well worth experiencing if you want to taste something other than the tourist-oriented predictability of the Waterfront. And quite safe during the day, though you will need to take taxis in the centre of town area after about 8.00 p.m.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.