Visited first time tonight. Picked due to reviews on trip advisor.
When we arrived the host seemed disinterested with us after learning we were there without a reservation, although 2/3rds of the tables I could see were open/vacant. We thought about leaving then but the piano player greeted us with warmth and was friendly. The host advised us he would let us stay if we would take a table next to the piano player/front door. Remember more tables were empty than full and were still empty when we left.
The disinterested host could have made a better choice in tables. I do not know if he was trying for aloof but he made a poor first impression for the restaurant.
After seating us he said our waitress would be right with us. Ten minutes later someone brought us water. After 20 minutes our waitress arrived and I realized it was the woman who I had seen talking to people and putting ornaments on a xmas tree. She seemed very professional and skilled at her job when she remembered we were there.
They were out of the filet mignon, as a second choice I went with fish. My wife's and my salads and entree were very tasty, other than the bones I found in my fish.
The high lite was the live piano player. He was talented and friendly.
I think we may try eating here again I would like to hope we just caught them on a bad night. But, next time.... I am making a reservation.
If you own or manage Mattina's Ristorante Italiano, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.