I was staying at the Hampton Inn so it was easy to go here for dinner. I wish I'd gone to Burger King next door. My partner ordered the All American Burger which has chilli on top. I ordered something that was supposed to feature "shaved beef and fried onions" in a sandwich. After a very long wait our food arrived. Mine was was not as described in the menu. It was thick cut beef (not shaved), no onions to be seen, and covered in mushrooms, green peppers and (I think) cheese. It was cold. When I complained to the "maitre d' " she said something like "I don't know what to tell you... it's the right sandwich but the wrong toppings". Hmm. I promptly told her I wanted something else - so I too ordered the burger. 10 minutes after my parter finished eating, my burger showed up. It was mediocre. Again, I wish I'd gone to Burger King.
Our server was really friendly and nice though so she still got a good tip. If you like a drink beware: the Navajo reservation is dry, so they don't serve alcohol anywhere. Bring your own and have it in your room. The restaurant were nice enough to lend us a corkscrew so that we could open a bottle of wine to have after dinner in our room.
If you own or manage Reuben Heflin, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.