This is my second time staying at this one-of-a-kind property. We rented the 'Beach House' in 2011 and again here I sit beside the perfect pool looking out at the perfect ocean. I'm not sure how to explain how wonderful it is here, but it has it all. I love the pool, and my partner prefers the ocean...we are both happy. The town of Montezuma is magical to say the least. The owners have been in this town for many many years, and I can sees why.
The full time caretakers are gracious, helpful, and accessible. My Spanish is poor, but it doesn't matter - they are patient and always keeping the place looking spectacular.
A few things to remember (these are the things that I love about my stay, but are important for others to consider): this is a place for the independent vacationer - you are never bothered by anyone and you make your own way for you stay. In the Beach House, the kitchen is well appointed though not extravagant. You may cook all the meals that you need or walk the VERY short distance to town for any number of meals. There is also access (your responsibility to schedule and setup) to a cook, massages, and we love going down the beach to Ylang Ylang Resort for afternoon cocktails.
Some other reviewers have called this place 'rustic' but I think this is misleading...this is the perfect combo of the relaxing, worry free Pura Vida lifestyle and the right amount of comfort that some travelers (including families) would expect. Extremely safe too.
For me, I will never consider going anywhere else for my perfect beach vacation. If you don't like it here, you're doing it wrong.