We visited the restaurant on advice from a local who said they had excellent cerviche and a set 3-course meal special, and since I'd already eaten another excellent cerviche at the local fish market we decided to give it a go for my birthday. Upstairs in a small mall on the northern end of the PV strip, it could be easily overlooked from the road, but seating was spacious and comfortable. The cerviche was very good, the set meal ($12 per person) was a spring roll appetiser and an excellent Cocunut encrusted sea bass a creme brulee with a birthday candle. drinks were delivered quickly and had plenty of kick - the wait staff were polite and friendly and the owner Andrew was extremely hospitable - even cracking out some excellent (if not deadly)Pomegranate Saki to help toast my birthday.
Overall I was a little disappointed with the price of food in Puerto Viejo, but this was an excellent meal, at a very reasonable price - and a perfect start to a birthday within a honeymoon in paradise.
If you own or manage Chile Rojo, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.