We loved the Hotel Punta Islita but probably wouldn't go back. Not because it wasn't awesome, it's just one of those been there done that things. We flew there via Sansa Air from San Jose, which is higly recommended after talking with others that drove, since it takes so long to drive and the roads stink big time. It's only a 35 min flight, although the plane is a 15 seater and the landing strip isn't large. It adds to the mystique of the whole experience.
We had 4 nights in Casita #23, which is just below the upper swimming pool. It was quiet and had a great view of the ocean. I was concerned about which one we would be in given some of the reviews I read and #23 or #22 were recommended. They also had units with a private plunge pool, but just a word of caution, some aren't totally private and can be viewed from the walkway down to the ocean. Some are probably very private. I would just check with the hotel about requesting a private one. We liked the outdoor jacuzzi, which isn't too warm or too hot - although during the hot part of the day, it could have been a little cooler - but that's what the pool is for. I'd rather have the private jacuzzi, with hammock and view of ocean. See the picture from our patio.
The hotel is very remote and there's not much to do in the city of Punta Islita itself. This place is great if you're looking for a hang out at the pool, swim in the ocean kind of place. They did have some cool activities - we did horseback riding and surf lessons. But if you're looking for something near a town with options for eating out, this isn't the place. The food was actually quite great and their brownies for desert were awesome - had them every night. I brought several bottles of wine with me which I bought pretty cheaply in San Jose, which I recommend since I hate overpaying for wine or beer.
My wife hates insects, and this is definetely the kind of place where you are going to see some wildlife. A snake slithered over my foot once and freaked me out, not to mention my wife, but was told it was harmless. They are lots of geckos, which my wife still didn't like, and there were a few iguanas around, which got onto the roof of our casista and sounded like a boa was killing a cow.
Our room was outstanding, the bed very comfortable, and the a/c worked great. The walk down to the ocean was about 10 minutes, but not bad. They have a shuttle that can take you back up. They are obviously in the process of adding to the hotel - a golf course, and other improvements, which should make it even better.
The Spa is totally awesome, and with the package we got on [--], it included a couples massage. I loved the shower up there - and it's quite relaxing, but if you want to add any services, the prices were like that in the US, just be prepared. Nothing is for free.














