This was recommended to us by one of our hotel staff. We had reasonably priced (relatively speaking) food. With local and more western food both available. The service was attentive, but it took a little bit of extra time on our second visit as we happened to overlap with a tour group of about 20. Has a good view of the volcano, when the clouds aren't covering it.
If you own or manage Que Rico Arenal, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.