I work in this area a lot and usually stay at the close-by Courtyard hotel but had never considered eating here. Finally I gave it a try and was nicely surprised. Keep in mind that I ate at the bar. I had one of their salads with a toping of a generous piece of salmon with clam strips as an appetizer. The salad and salmon were great. The clam strips were crispier than I prefer but were still good. On my next trip I had their fried tilapia fish tacos and they were both plentiful and excellent. Their home made bread pudding was outstanding and made from their own loaves of fresh bread. My biggest compliment goes to Jan who was very friendly and helpful in suggesting an entree. The aquarium was very relaxing and gave me something to occupy my time since I was alone. I will definitely go back.
If you own or manage ISLAMORADA FISH COMPANY, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.