Go for the food, not the atmosphere. Excellent food, as good as any I had in Germany. Co-worker who had lived in Germany for a few years said the same thing. We each had a different schnitzel, with potato salad and he had kraut and I had red cabbage. Not one complaint. Service was good, not obtrusive, but there when we needed something. The desserts, well, if you don't save room for a dessert, you are making a big mistake. I had German chocolate cake and my co-worker had the Black Forest cake. Huge slices! After such big amounts of food on the plates, and such huge desserts, we rolled out of there totally satisfied. If you are in Huntsville, this is a "must go" place.
If you own or manage Hildegards German Cuisine, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.