Smoked hilsa, boneless hilsa, gondhoraj bhetki, aam-kasundi bhendi (forgot the exact name) are must-try. They also have bhapa sandesh (expensive, but you'll forget the price once it melts in your mouth).
Don't try daab chingri or chingri malaikari. Not worth the price.
If you own or manage Oh! Calcutta, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.