We stayed in Milk Bay for a couple of nights in August. Its a beautiful resort made up on individual bungalows surrounded by bamboo and shaded walkways. Its right on the beach, has a large clean pool and has good bar and food facilities. Our bungalow was right beside the beach, was clean, spacious and beautifully decorated. Staff are exceptionally friendly, helpful and funny and really engage with the guests. Definately some of the best staff we came across on our trip. Another plus is that the hotel provide a free pick up to the pier.
The only downside is that your a bit removed from the larger towns on the island.