When I walked in this place I was floored -- seriously, floored -- by the atmosphere. It was a beautiful night, and the restaurant (it's really a full-service restaurant, not a cafe) unfolds over three levels underneath an enormous tropical tree. There is tasteful lighting and it's just the pleasant type of place in which I could sit for hours.
...which is precisely what we did. Twenty minutes of sitting before our server came over to deliver menus. Another 20 minutes until he came back. Thirty minutes for the appetizer to come. Forty-five minutes after that before our meals came. All told, this was an investment of over two hours for a simple meal which was good for most of us -- the rosemary and parmesan pizza was truly excellent as an appetizer -- but not incredible. I'd go back for the pizza and the atmosphere, but only with a LOT of time to kill.
If you own or manage Cafecito, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.