...this is an old, historic, place! We searched our Gatsby's right away because we knew how historical it was with the liked of Washington and Jefferson being known to hang there. The "proprietor" was excellent telling us the history of the place and what is still original in the tavern--lots! Having just gotten off a plane, we were happy with our food, and ventured to try some "colonial"-type dishes including "Peanut Soup". (Not a knock on the food at the restaurant which was excellent, but could have passed on the soup. Tasted rich, like melted peanut butter.) Very nice meal! Go for the food, stay to hear the interesting stuff about the building, and remember the historic place you are sitting in.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.