We love their pepperoni with extra cheese pizza and the cheesecake is delicious. My favorite is the pistachio and cherry cheesecake. So good! If you like thin NY style pizza, you'll love it. We have tried some of the other specialty pizzas and the fettuccini Alfredo and were not impressed. Stick with the basics here. They also have delicious meatballs. We order them as a side sometimes.
If you own or manage Brooklyn's Old Neighborhood Style Pizzeria, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.