We stopped in as it was the only restaurant we could find serving food after the plays let out at the OSF. At that time of night, they said they were serving a limited cafe menu, which we were fine with. I ordered a cup of soup and the fruit/cheese plate. The soup was okay, but the fruit/cheese plate was awful - both the watermelon and honeydew melon on it had gone bad (sour and soggy), while the cheese was limp. My boyfriend ordered the caesar salad, but only had a little as it tasted very strongly of lime. Even the drinks from the bar weren't very good. The waitress had to ask us what was in a Dark and Stormy (a pretty basic drink that's hard to screw up), and even then it wasn't good.
The restaurant clearly doesn't want to be serving late night diners, so it shouldn't be offering a menu at all since it's so crappy.
If you own or manage Martino's Restaurant & Bar, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.