I noticed a lot of the negative reviews had to do with the dining arrangements. (I also noticed that of the 2 "terrible" reviews one was written by a yankee so that one can be ignored out of hand).
We visit the beach 12 months a year. Sometimes, ladies and gentlemen, one ought choose a dining location other than one that only offers outdoor seating. That is just a tip for those who are taking notes. That being said, this is a great go-to spot for shoulder season. For the money the fried seafood is right on. In fact, you can spend a lot more for mess that is not as good. The burgers will put you to sleep in 30 minutes.
I'm not saying I'd make a road trip just to hit the Shark Shack but if you are staying in the area you will probably drive by several times. If the crowds and weather are right and you are not frightened by your cardiologists admonitions, park your rig and grab a substantial eat with your hands meal. Somebody in the group needs to order the grouper bites for sharing.
If you own or manage Shark Shack, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.