Well I was surprised by the rating of the hotel on TripAdvisor, not because the hotel is bad, but because it's pretty average and a #1 rating is surprising. I would not suggest going during the low season (we went in May) because it doesn't seem as if they are really prepared to have guests at that time.
Good: Amazing view, cozy rooms, quiet area, delicious food, friendly dog on the property, hot showers
Bad: You have to specify when you want your hot shower, breakfast was smaller than other hotels I've been to, the hotel is far away from the road and we got lost, not much light inside or outside
There are good and bad parts of the lodge, I'd say it was pretty average. Maybe its better during the tourist season?