Yes, the plaza setting is attractive. Can't say that about the food and service- very average. Calamari and ceviche to start with were ok. The mains- pad thai and langostini noodles (the lagtter around 20,000COP more expensive) were pretty much the same thing. We waited for the table for over 40mins at a pretty soulless bar. You can do so much better in Cartagena for the price.
If you own or manage Cafe San Pedro, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.