We arrived by boat on July 7th. We were seated on deck under the stairs and as soon as we were seated another table in front of us opened up so we asked the hostess if we could sit there. She cleaned the table and we were seated. After a few minutes we were informed that we would have to move because this table was reserved. It was not the young hostess fault, she was sweet. It was a bit embarrassing however, moving twice. The table under the stairs was next to the station where the owner/manager was constantly dipping a rag in questionable water to wipe down tables and actually complaining??? about the busy week they had!!!This was @ app. 3pm and we were informed that they were out of 4 of the 11 apps.. Wow! We actually felt as if our presence was in an imposition! We had drinks and apps and they did not even bring two plates. Food was okay. Bloody mary was excellent and lemon martini was just okay. We left asap and rode all the way across the lake to Lagos in Meredith. What a difference: we were greeted warmly and the service was exceptional.The food was superb also...but that is another review!
If you own or manage Shibley's at the Pier, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.