If you go in knowing that the food won't be the best you'll have on the island but that the atmosphere will be worth it, then you'll have a great time. Warning -- the portions are HUGE so know that you can split plates and still have plenty to eat. This is worth the stop for the atmosphere alone. Have yourself a Cisco Whale's Tale at the bar before you eat and watch whatever game they have up on the flat screen. Bartenders are friendly as are the regulars.
If you own or manage Brotherhood of Thieves, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.