I reviewed this place from my first experience, and didn't care for the pizza at all. The owner offered me a free pizza to come in and try it again. My review was done from memory, and to be fair, I went in for a second try so I could review a recent meal here. The fact thatthe owner was trying to step up to the plate and have me come in for a 2nd try (on him) says a lot. He understand customer service, and I applaud him for that. I have to say that my pizza was much better this second time around. Maybe i just hit this place on a bad night the first time.
Keep in mind that pizza is a very opinionated food. What one person loves another can't stand....such is the case with many restaurants. I thought the pizza was quite good, maybe just not my favorite type. I think the first time I had pizza here and called it "doughy" and think I may have gotten a pizza that was under-cooked. Tonight's pizza was cooked perfectly, and was pretty good. I'm glad I came back in to try it again, and was pleasantly surprised, and enjoyed it. I won't lie and say it's my favorite in town, but I'm picky when it comes to my favorite pizza. I think if you haven't tried Cottage pizza, you should give it a try, I have friends that love it. I just happen to have different preferences.
Hats off to the owner and staff...they were very professional, and went the extra mile to try and keep a customer happy....good job!!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.