We wondered whether we were in the right spot. Having read all the raves, we were looking forward to a spectacular meal. The ambiance and waitress were as nice as your reviewers claimed. However, we found the food bland.
I had the house salad (good) and a crispy cod special that was presented attractively but was boring. Cod needs something to give it a little oomph; this didn't have it.
My wife of over 50 years opted for chopped chicken liver and mussels (so highly praised by others). The chicken liver was OK - my bubbe's was as good or better. We have eaten mussels all over the world (and frequently at home) and she pronounced hers dull. Maybe the flavoring for the mussels was a bit too subtle for her taste. She passed the sausage to me. It was disappointingly bland.
I should add the couple we were with praised their meals. For interesting food in Amherst, we prefer the Monkey Bar, by far.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.