I've been to Atlantic Sea Grill several times and have found the food to be consistently good. Everything is fresh and cooked very well. The most recent visit, my dining companion and I shared the seafood rangoon which were delicious; our two main courses - grilled swordfish and stuff shrimp - were perfectly cooked. The main courses come with two side dishes, and here's almost too much food. All their waitstaff are very friendly, the clientele seems older, mostly locals. They have a short wine list, but with some well known wines, and some nice sounding cocktails. My only "complaint" would be my Melon Martini, which sounded very good, but seemed to be mostly alcohol which is not appealing for me personally. Also, this restaurant is attached to a fish market, and has some take out options.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.