If you need some quiet time away from the usual Puerto Galera crowd, Talipanan would be the perfect choice. There are fewer resorts to choose from, but the beach is as great and clear. It's really just a peaceful and quaint version of White Beach. The restaurants close early so the place is really quiet at night. In case you'd still want to drink/party during nighttime, you can still go to White Beach just by riding the tricycles by the main road, which costs around 100 pesos for a group of maybe 3-5.
From the Batangas port, you can get the boats that can go directly to Talipanan, so you wouldn't have to get off at White Beach.
If you own or manage Talipanan Beach, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.