Took my three boys up there for some gelato based on the reviews here. It's a bit of a walk from the souk but we found it no problem (be warned, it's nowhere near where it says it is on the Trip Advisor map).
There was about 15-20 different flavours to choose from and the ones we had were all very nice (we all had different flavours between the four of us). Only 4 stars though, as we wanted cones and they only had cups. It's not that big of a deal, but surely an ice cream shop has about 4 things it needs to do. Stock ice cream/gelato, cups, cones and coffee. It's not that hard!
Also, I saw someone else complained about the lack of seating downstairs. I have no idea what they're talking about and was expecting somewhere really pokey when we got there. There is a very large seating area outside with lots of relaxing bean bags around the place. Given it's currently christmas which is the coldest time of year and we happily sat outside, I would assume this is more than acceptable for most of the rest of the year as well
If you own or manage Panna Gusto Italiano, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.